Brooklinen Sheets Review: My Honest Take on the Internet‘s Favorite Bedding
Hey there, fellow sheet enthusiasts! If you‘re anything like me, you‘re always on the hunt for bedding that looks and feels amazing without totally blowing your budget. So when I kept hearing rave reviews about Brooklinen sheets, I knew I had to try them for myself.
In this post, I‘m sharing my full experience with Brooklinen‘s best-selling sheets, from the unboxing to the first sleep and beyond. I‘ll give you all the details on the material, feel, fit, and more so you can decide if these sheets are right for you. Plus, I‘ll compare Brooklinen to some other popular brands and answer all your burning questions about care, returns, and longevity.
But first, let‘s start with a quick overview of what you can expect from this Brooklinen sheets review:
- Detailed look at 4 sheet sets: Classic Percale, Luxe Sateen, Linen, Heathered Cashmere
- Pros and cons based on my experience + thousands of customer reviews
- Comparison to Parachute, Boll & Branch, Snowe, and more
- Care instructions and product policies
- Answers to FAQs about quality, comfort, durability
- My honest take on whether Brooklinen sheets are worth the hype
Ready to dive in? Let‘s go!
About Brooklinen
Before we get into the sheets themselves, let‘s talk a bit about the brand behind them. Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer bedding company that was founded in 2014 by husband-and-wife team Rich and Vicki Fulop. Their goal was simple: to create luxury hotel-quality sheets at a fraction of the price.
By cutting out the middleman and selling exclusively online, Brooklinen is able to offer high-end sheets for a lot less than traditional retailers. They‘ve since expanded into other home essentials like towels, robes, and loungewear, but the sheets are still their bread and butter.
One thing I really appreciate about Brooklinen is their commitment to transparency and sustainability. All of their sheets are OEKO-TEX certified, which means they‘ve been tested for harmful chemicals and substances. They also use long-staple cotton and linen, which are more durable and environmentally friendly than cheaper alternatives.
But enough about the company, let‘s get into the good stuff: the sheets!
Brooklinen Sheet Sets: Materials and Options
Brooklinen offers four main sheet sets: Classic Percale, Luxe Sateen, Linen, and Heathered Cashmere. Each set comes with a flat sheet, fitted sheet, and 2 pillowcases (twin/twin XL sets only come with 1 pillowcase). You can also mix and match colors or buy individual pieces if you want.
Here‘s a quick breakdown of each material:
Classic Percale Sheets
If you like a crisp, cool feel, you‘ll love Brooklinen‘s Classic Percale sheets. These are the brand‘s best-selling set, and for good reason. They‘re made from 100% long-staple cotton with a 270 thread count, which gives them a lightweight, breathable feel that‘s perfect for hot sleepers.
The percale weave also makes these sheets incredibly durable and resistant to pilling, so they‘ll still look great after years of use. I‘ve had my set for over a year now and they‘ve only gotten softer with each wash.
Pros:
- Crisp, cool, breathable feel
- Durable and long-lasting
- Generously sized fitted sheet (15" deep)
- OEKO-TEX certified
- 365-day return policy + lifetime warranty
Cons:
- Wrinkles easily if not taken out of dryer right away
- Limited color options
- Some reviewers find them too crisp/scratchy at first
Price: Starting at $129 for a full set
Luxe Sateen Sheets
If you prefer a silkier, more lustrous feel, check out the Luxe Sateen sheets. These are made from the same 100% long-staple cotton as the percale, but with a higher 480 thread count and a sateen weave. This gives them a buttery-soft feel and subtle sheen that‘s ultra-luxurious.
I was a bit hesitant to try sateen sheets at first, as I tend to sleep hot and was worried they‘d be too heavy. But Brooklinen‘s sateen is surprisingly lightweight and breathable, while still feeling incredibly smooth against the skin. They also drape beautifully over the mattress and have a slightly more formal look than the percale.
Pros:
- Silky-soft, smooth feel
- Lightweight and breathable
- Lustrous sheen for a luxe look
- OEKO-TEX certified
- 365-day return policy + lifetime warranty
Cons:
- More expensive than percale
- Snag easier than percale
- Can feel a bit slippery at first
Price: Starting at $149 for a full set
Linen Sheets
For a more casual, lived-in look, you can‘t go wrong with Brooklinen‘s linen sheets. These are made from 100% Belgian and French flax, which is known for its durability, breathability, and effortless style. The linen is stonewashed for added softness and comes in a range of beautiful colors.
I absolutely adore the relaxed, slightly rumpled texture of these sheets. They have a substantial weight to them without feeling heavy, and get softer and cozier with every wash. I also appreciate that they‘re naturally temperature-regulating, so they keep me cool in summer and warm in winter.
Pros:
- Relaxed, effortlessly chic look
- Breathable and moisture-wicking
- Ideal for year-round comfort
- Stonewashed for added softness
- OEKO-TEX certified
- 365-day return policy + lifetime warranty
Cons:
- Significantly more expensive than cotton
- Wrinkles very easily
- Requires gentle cycle + air drying
- Some reviewers find them rough at first
Price: Starting at $249 for a full set
Heathered Cashmere Sheets
For the ultimate luxury, splurge on Brooklinen‘s Heathered Cashmere sheets. These are made from a blend of 95% cotton and 5% Himalayan cashmere for an ultra-soft, cozy feel. The unique diagonal weave creates a heathered texture that‘s both stylish and snuggly.
I‘ll be honest, I was a bit skeptical about cashmere sheets at first. I love cashmere sweaters, but wasn‘t sure how the material would hold up in bedding. But Brooklinen‘s blend is actually quite practical – the cotton makes them durable and easy to care for, while the cashmere adds an unbelievable softness.
Pros:
- Incredibly soft and cozy
- Unique heathered texture
- Breathable yet warm
- Durable cotton blend
- OEKO-TEX certified
- 365-day return policy + lifetime warranty
Cons:
- Very expensive
- Only 5 color options
- Requires delicate cycle + air drying
- May shed a bit at first
Price: Starting at $279 for a full set
Brooklinen vs. Other Sheet Brands
Of course, Brooklinen isn‘t the only DTC sheet brand out there. I‘ve also tried sheets from several of their competitors, so I thought I‘d share a quick comparison:
| Brand | Material Options | Price (Queen) | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brooklinen | Percale, Sateen, Linen, Cashmere | $149 – $279 | High quality, OEKO-TEX certified, generous sizing | Wrinkles easily, limited colors |
| Parachute | Percale, Sateen, Linen | $149 – $169 | Soft, lightweight, OEKO-TEX certified | No top sheet, thin elastic on fitted sheet |
| Boll & Branch | Percale, Sateen | $200 – $295 | Organic cotton, Fair Trade certified | Expensive, only 2 materials |
| Snowe | Percale, Sateen, Linen | $195 – $265 | Italian milled, OEKO-TEX certified | Sizing runs small, no warranty |
As you can see, Brooklinen offers the widest range of materials at a fairly competitive price point. They‘re not the cheapest option out there, but I think they offer the best balance of quality, comfort, and value.
That said, the "best" sheets for you will ultimately come down to your personal preferences and priorities. If organic cotton and fair trade practices are important to you, Boll & Branch is a great choice. If you prefer a super minimalist look and don‘t mind skipping the top sheet, Parachute‘s sets are very chic. And if you want a slightly more budget-friendly option, Snowe is definitely worth checking out.
FAQs About Brooklinen Sheets
Before I wrap up this review, I wanted to address some of the most common questions I see about Brooklinen sheets:
How long do Brooklinen sheets last?
With proper care, Brooklinen sheets can easily last for 3-5 years or longer. The long-staple cotton and linen they use is incredibly durable and resistant to pilling, tearing, and fading. I‘ve had my percale set for over a year and it still looks and feels like new.
That said, the lifespan of your sheets will depend on how often you use and wash them, as well as how well you follow the care instructions (more on that in a bit). Using a mattress protector and rotating your sheets can also help them last longer.
Do Brooklinen sheets pill?
Pilling is a common issue with lower-quality sheets, but Brooklinen‘s long-staple cotton and linen are resistant to pilling. I haven‘t noticed any pilling on my sheets, even after multiple washes.
However, if you do notice some pilling, there are a few things you can do to minimize it:
- Wash your sheets separately from other clothes/linens
- Use a gentle detergent and avoid fabric softener
- Wash on a delicate cycle in cold water
- Tumble dry on low or air dry
- Use a fabric shaver to remove any pills that do form
Are Brooklinen sheets worth the price?
This is a tough question to answer, as "worth it" means different things to different people. Objectively, Brooklinen sheets are more expensive than what you‘ll find at most big box stores. A queen set can run you anywhere from $150 to $300 depending on the material.
So what are you paying for? In my opinion, the main thing that sets Brooklinen apart is the quality of the materials and construction. The long-staple cotton and linen they use is simply a cut above what you‘ll find in cheaper sheets, and it shows in the feel, durability, and look of the fabric. The fitted sheets also have deep pockets and strong elastic that keeps them in place, which is a small detail but one I really appreciate.
Of course, there are plenty of other great sheet brands out there at lower price points. If you‘re on a tight budget, you can definitely find some nice cotton or microfiber sets for under $100. But if you‘re looking for something a bit more special and are willing to invest in your sleep, I do think Brooklinen is worth the splurge.
As a rule of thumb, I think spending around $150-$200 on a quality sheet set is a reasonable middle ground. That‘s enough to get you a well-made set that will feel great and last for years, but won‘t totally break the bank.
How do I care for my Brooklinen sheets?
Caring for your Brooklinen sheets is actually pretty simple, but there are a few key things to keep in mind:
- Always wash your sheets before first use
- Wash in cold water on a gentle cycle
- Use a mild, liquid detergent and avoid fabric softener
- Don‘t overload the washing machine
- Tumble dry on low heat or air dry
- Remove from dryer promptly to minimize wrinkling
- Iron on low heat if needed (except for linen)
For linen sheets, Brooklinen actually recommends machine washing on a gentle cycle with cool water and mild detergent. Then tumble dry on low heat until slightly damp, and remove promptly. You can shake out the sheets to help release wrinkles, but don‘t iron them – the wrinkles are part of the charm!
I‘d also recommend using a mattress protector to keep your sheets cleaner and help them last longer. And if you have multiple sets, rotating them regularly can help extend their lifespan as well.
Brooklinen has a full care guide on their website with more detailed instructions for each material.
My Verdict: Are Brooklinen Sheets Worth It?
So, after sleeping on Brooklinen sheets for over a year, what‘s my verdict? In short, I‘m a fan. I think Brooklinen delivers on their promise of luxury hotel-quality sheets at a more accessible price point. The sheets look and feel amazing, come in a variety of stylish colors and patterns, and have held up beautifully with regular use.
That said, Brooklinen sheets aren‘t necessarily for everyone. If you‘re someone who prioritizes value over luxury, or simply doesn‘t like the feel of crisp cotton sheets, there are definitely cheaper options out there that will get the job done. And while I appreciate Brooklinen‘s OEKO-TEX certification and long-staple materials, some people may prefer the organic or fair trade certifications of other brands.
But if you‘re looking for a special set of sheets that will make your bed feel like a 5-star hotel, Brooklinen is definitely worth checking out. The Classic Percale set is a great place to start if you like a cool, crisp feel, while the Luxe Sateen is perfect if you prefer something silkier. And if you want something a bit more unique, the Linen and Heathered Cashmere sets are both gorgeous and incredibly cozy.
Whichever set you choose, I think you‘ll be impressed with the quality and attention to detail of Brooklinen sheets. And with their generous 365-day return policy and lifetime warranty, you can try them out risk-free and invest with confidence.
At the end of the day, great sheets are an investment in your sleep and overall well-being. And in my experience, Brooklinen sheets are an investment that pays off in spades. Sweet dreams!
