Mayfair Toilet Seats Review: Why I‘m Never Going Back to Basic

Hey there, home décor divas! When was the last time you gave a second thought to your toilet seat? If you‘re anything like I used to be, the answer is probably "never". But hear me out – upgrading to a Mayfair toilet seat was one of the best decisions I‘ve made for my booty and my bathroom.

In this tell-all review, I‘m diving deep into the world of Mayfair to find out what makes their seats so special. I‘ve scoured the specs, combed through customer reviews, and spent quality time perched upon their top models to bring you the full scoop. So put down the lid, grab a latte, and let‘s dish about why Mayfair is my new "throne" away from home.

Why I Switched to Mayfair Toilet Seats

I‘ll admit, I used to think all toilet seats were created equal. Boy, was I wrong! It wasn‘t until I moved into a new apartment with a flimsy, constantly-loosening seat that I realized how much a quality throne matters. After one too many middle-of-the-night scares (you know the kind), I started researching upgrades and discovered Mayfair.

What initially drew me to Mayfair was their incredible selection. They have tons of styles, colors, and configurations to suit any taste or tushy. Plus, their seats are packed with cool features I never even knew I needed, like slow-close hinges and built-in nightlights.

But Mayfair isn‘t just about bells and whistles – they‘re seriously focused on quality and comfort too. All of their seats are made with top-notch materials like real wood and heavy-duty plastics. They also boast exclusive technologies like their STA-TITE fastening system that keeps seats from shifting or loosening over time.

The more I learned about Mayfair, the more I knew I had to try one for myself. So I took the plunge and ordered their top-selling Caswell Slow-Close seat in glossy white. And let me tell you, I‘ve never looked back.

Mayfair Caswell Toilet Seat Review

The Mayfair Caswell is like the little black dress of toilet seats – a classic that never goes out of style. This sleek, no-nonsense seat has all the essential features you need and nothing you don‘t. It‘s the perfect choice for anyone who wants a durable, comfortable throne without too much fuss.

One of the first things I noticed about the Caswell was how solid it feels. The glossy polypropylene material is thick and sturdy, yet still looks elegant. I was also impressed by how easy it was to install. The STA-TITE fastening system ensures a tight, wiggle-free fit without the need for constant retightening.

But my favorite feature of the Caswell has to be the slow-close hinges. No more startling seat slams or pinched fingers! The whisper-close damping gently lowers the seat and lid, making midnight bathroom trips a breeze. It‘s a small luxury, but one I‘ve come to really appreciate.

The Caswell comes in both round and elongated sizes to fit most toilet configurations. It‘s available in a handful of neutral shades like white, bone, and biscuit to complement any bathroom decor. Plus, it‘s affordably priced between $30-$50 depending on the size and finish.

After living with the Caswell for a few months, I can confidently say it‘s a fantastic value. The construction is top-notch and all the features work flawlessly. The only minor downside is the glossy finish can show scratches more easily than a matte seat. But for the price and performance, I‘m more than happy to overlook a few imperfections.

Mayfair NextStep2 Toilet Seat Review

If you‘ve got little ones at home, you know that potty training can be a real challenge. Between constant clean-ups and clunky training seats, it‘s enough to make any parent dread the process. That‘s why I was so intrigued by the Mayfair NextStep2 – a ingenious all-in-one seat that combines an adult throne with a built-in toddler trainer.

The NextStep2 features a standard adult-sized seat with a mini magnetic child seat nested inside. When nature calls for your little one, they can simply unlatch their petite potty and get down to business. Both seats include slow-close hinges to prevent pinched fingers and startling slams.

As a mom of two, I really appreciate how the NextStep2 streamlines the potty training process. There‘s no need for a separate training seat that constantly needs to be cleaned and stored. And when your mini-me graduates to the big league, the built-in tot seat is barely noticeable. Talk about a space saver!

Another perk of the NextStep2 is how easy it is to clean. The seat is crafted from a single piece of polypropylene, so there are no cracks or crevices for gunk to get trapped in. And if you need to do a deep clean, the seat pops right off thanks to Mayfair‘s Quick-Release hinges.

Now, I will say the NextStep2 is a bit pricier than a basic seat at around $60. But considering you‘re getting two seats in one, it‘s actually a pretty solid value. It fits both round and elongated toilet bowls and comes in a crisp white finish.

If you‘re in the throes of potty training or have a little one on the way, I highly recommend giving the NextStep2 a try. It‘s made the process so much easier for my family and I love that it will grow with my kiddos. Plus, anything that makes parenting a little less messy is a win in my book!

Comparing Mayfair to Other Toilet Seat Brands

Of course, Mayfair isn‘t the only game in town when it comes to high-quality toilet seats. So how do they stack up against the competition? To find out, I pitted Mayfair against two other leading brands – Kohler and American Standard.

Mayfair vs. Kohler

Kohler is a household name in bathroom fixtures, so I was curious to see how their seats compared to Mayfair. Like Mayfair, Kohler offers a wide range of styles from classic wood to modern plastics. They also have some innovative features like LED nightlights and built-in bidet cleansing.

However, I found that Kohler seats tended to be a bit pricier than comparable Mayfair models. For example, Kohler‘s Cachet Quiet-Close seat retails for around $60, while Mayfair‘s similar Caswell Slow-Close seat goes for about $30-$40.

Kohler does offer a few more finish options than Mayfair, which is nice if you‘re looking for an exact match to your bathroom fixtures. But in terms of overall quality and value, I think Mayfair comes out ahead.

Mayfair vs. American Standard

American Standard is another major player in the world of toilets and seats. They offer a solid array of classic and contemporary seats with all the essential features like slow-close hinges and quick-release seats.

One area where American Standard shines is their EverClean surface technology, which inhibits the growth of bacteria, mold, and mildew. This is a nice perk for those who want a low-maintenance throne.

However, I found that American Standard‘s seats didn‘t feel quite as sturdy as Mayfair‘s. The plastics were a bit thinner and flexed more under weight. They also tended to have more visible seams and a less polished look overall.

Pricewise, American Standard seats are pretty comparable to Mayfair‘s, ranging from $30-$60 depending on the model. But given the choice, I‘d personally opt for Mayfair‘s heavier-duty construction and sleeker designs.

The Bottom Line on Mayfair Toilet Seats

So after all my research and hands-on testing, where do I land on Mayfair toilet seats? In a word – obsessed! Mayfair has completely converted me from a toilet seat skeptic to a bona fide throne snob.

I love that Mayfair combines high-end features like slow-close hinges and no-slip seats with durable, easy-to-clean materials. Their STA-TITE fastening system is a game-changer for anyone who‘s sick of constantly retightening a wobbly seat. And I really appreciate their focus on eco-friendly practices and water conservation – it‘s nice to know my purchase is helping the planet too.

But beyond all the bells and whistles, what really sets Mayfair apart for me is their commitment to quality and customer service. Their seats are built to last, with many models boasting generous multi-year warranties. And if you do run into any issues, Mayfair‘s customer support team is top-notch.

Pricewise, Mayfair seats are very reasonable considering all the features you get. Most of their models range from $30-$60, which is on par with other major brands. And in my opinion, the added comfort and peace of mind are well worth the investment.

If I had to nitpick, I guess I would say I wish Mayfair offered a few more finish options beyond the standard white, bone, and biscuit shades. Some of their wood seats could also be prone to chipping if you‘re not careful. But overall, these are pretty minor gripes.

At the end of the day, I wholeheartedly recommend giving Mayfair toilet seats a try. Your bum (and your plumber) will thank you! With so many great models to choose from, you‘re sure to find the perfect throne to suit your needs and budget. Trust me, once you go Mayfair, you‘ll never go back to basic.