ACH vs Credit Card Payments in 2024: The Ultimate Guide for Businesses

As a business owner, few decisions impact your bottom line as much as how you get paid. While you have more options than ever in 2024, the two most common payment methods still boil down to ACH vs credit cards. But which one is right for your business?

In this ultimate guide, we‘ll dive deep into the key differences between ACH and credit card payments. With an objective look at the latest data, trends, and expert insights, you‘ll come away empowered to make the smartest choice for your payment processing in 2024 and beyond.

ACH Payments: How They Work and Why Businesses Use Them

ACH stands for Automated Clearing House, an electronic network for financial transactions in the United States. ACH payments allow funds to move between bank accounts without the need for paper checks, wire transfers, credit card networks, or cash.

Here‘s how a typical ACH payment works:

  1. The customer provides their bank account information (routing and account number) to authorize the transaction.
  2. The merchant submits an ACH entry to their bank or ACH operator.
  3. The ACH network clears the payment and settles the funds between the customer‘s and merchant‘s banks.
  4. The merchant receives the funds in their account, typically within 1-2 business days.

There are two main types of ACH transactions that businesses can leverage:

  • ACH Debit (also known as "pulling" funds) – The merchant initiates a payment to withdraw funds from the customer‘s account. Common use cases include recurring bills and subscriptions.

  • ACH Credit (also known as "pushing" funds) – The customer initiates a payment to send funds to the merchant‘s account. Direct deposits and B2B vendor payments often use this method.

According to NACHA, the ACH network processed 29.5 billion payment transactions valued at $73.8 trillion in 2021 alone. So why do businesses use ACH? The top reasons include:

  • Cost savings – ACH is one of the cheapest electronic payment methods, with low flat fees (more on this later)
  • Cash flow – ACH payments typically settle within 1-2 business days, faster than paper checks
  • Convenience – Funds transfer automatically, no need to chase down checks or make manual deposits
  • Recurring billing – ACH supports automated recurring payments to increase predictability
  • B2B preference – Many B2B customers strongly prefer ACH over credit cards or checks

Credit Card Payments: How They Work and Why Businesses Use Them

Credit card payments are a form of "card not present" transaction that occurs when customers provide their credit card details (number, expiration date, CVV code) to a merchant. This can happen through an online payment gateway, virtual terminal, mobile card reader, or by manually keying in the information.

Here‘s a simplified look at how credit card processing works:

  1. The customer provides their credit card information to the merchant to authorize a purchase.
  2. The merchant submits a request to their acquiring bank/payment processor.
  3. The payment processor routes the transaction to the credit card network (Visa, Mastercard, etc.).
  4. The credit card network clears the transaction with the customer‘s issuing bank and puts a hold on the funds.
  5. The issuing bank approves or declines the transaction.
  6. If approved, the merchant‘s account is credited, typically within 1-3 business days. The actual funds are transferred later.

Some of the key players involved in every credit card transaction include:

  • Cardholder – The customer who provides their credit card to make a purchase
  • Merchant – The business who accepts the card as payment for goods or services
  • Issuing Bank – The bank that provides the credit card to the customer
  • Credit Card Network – Visa, Mastercard, American Express or Discover
  • Acquiring Bank – The merchant‘s bank that processes payments on their behalf
  • Payment Processor – The service provider that handles the processing tech and relationships between the merchant, acquiring bank and card networks

Despite the rise of alternative payment methods, credit cards remain hugely popular. The Nilson Report projects that credit card purchase volume in the U.S. alone will reach $11.18 trillion by 2027. The main reasons businesses accept credit cards include:

  • Convenience – Credit cards are the most widely used and accepted payment method
  • Increased sales – Customers often spend more when paying with credit vs cash or debit
  • Faster funding – Merchants typically receive funds within 1-3 business days of the transaction
  • Trust signals – Accepting credit cards builds credibility and legitimacy for a business
  • Chargeback protection – Merchants have some fraud and chargeback protection through their processor

ACH vs Credit Cards: Fees Compared

One of the biggest factors in choosing ACH or credit card payments is the costs involved. While ACH is known for being cheaper than credit cards, the specific fees depend on your payment processor and business details.

ACH Payment Fees

ACH fees are relatively simple and straightforward compared to credit cards. Most ACH processors charge a flat fee per transaction, typically between $0.25 to $0.75. Some may also charge a small percentage fee, around 0.5% to 1%.

For example, let‘s say you use Stripe as your ACH payment processor. Stripe charges:

  • 0.8% per ACH debit transaction, with a $5 cap
  • $1 per ACH credit transaction
  • No setup, monthly, or annual fees

So if you processed 100 ACH debit transactions at $100 each in a month, your total ACH fees would be $80.00 (0.8% x $100 x 100).

Credit Card Payment Fees

Credit card processing fees are notoriously complex, with several types of fees that vary based on the card, transaction, and processor. The three main components are:

  1. Interchange fees – Set by the credit card networks and paid to the issuing bank. These make up the bulk of processing fees and typically range from 1.15% + $0.05 to 3.25% + $0.10 per transaction.

  2. Assessment fees – Also set by the card networks and paid to them directly. These are usually around 0.14% per transaction.

  3. Payment processor fees – Charged by your processor and can include flat fees, percentage fees, monthly/annual fees and more.

So let‘s say you processed 100 credit card transactions at $100 each in a month with Stripe. Here‘s how your fees might break down:

  • Interchange fees (2.5% + $0.10) – $250
  • Assessment fees (0.14%) – $14
  • Stripe‘s flat fee ($0.30) – $30
  • Stripe‘s percentage fee (2.9%) – $290

Your total credit card processing fees would be $584, or 5.84% of your total transaction volume.

Clearly, there‘s a big difference in cost between ACH and credit card transactions. For businesses with thin margins or high transaction volumes, those savings can really add up.

ACH vs Credit Cards: Which Is Right for Your Business?

Choosing between ACH and credit card payments ultimately depends on your business model, industry, customer preferences and processing costs. Here‘s a quick guide to help you decide:

ACH payments are usually better for:

  • B2B businesses – Many B2B buyers prefer ACH over cards due to lower fees, higher limits, and simpler reconciliation. In fact, 64% of B2B payments are made by ACH.

  • Recurring billing – If you charge customers on a recurring basis (weekly, monthly, etc.), ACH can save you a lot in fees over time. Automatic payments also reduce churn.

  • High-risk merchants – Businesses deemed "high risk" by credit card processors can often still qualify for ACH payments, as the underwriting standards are not as strict.

  • Large transactions – While ACH limits vary by processor, they‘re often much higher than credit card limits. ACH can support transactions up to $100,000 or more in some cases.

Credit card payments are usually better for:

  • Ecommerce businesses – The vast majority of online shoppers prefer to pay with credit or debit cards. Not accepting them is a huge friction point.

  • In-person retail – Customers expect to be able to swipe, dip, or tap their credit cards in-store. Failing to accept them means losing sales.

  • Occasional billing – If you bill customers infrequently or for varying amounts (like a freelancer or consultant), credit cards offer more flexibility and lower setup costs than ACH.

  • B2C subscriptions – Consumer subscription businesses often start with credit card payments because they‘re familiar and easy for customers. You can introduce ACH later as an option.

Of course, you don‘t have to choose just one. Many businesses accept both ACH and credit cards to maximize payment options for customers. You can also offer incentives or discounts to encourage customers to pay via ACH and save on fees.

How to Start Accepting ACH and Credit Card Payments

Once you‘ve decided which payment methods are right for your business, here are your next steps to start accepting them:

ACH Payments

  1. Choose an ACH payment processor – Look for a reputable provider like Stripe, Square, or Bill.com that offers competitive rates and integrates with your existing systems.

  2. Set up your account – You‘ll need to provide business details and bank account information for underwriting and processing.

  3. Integrate ACH into your payment flow – Use your processor‘s API, hosted checkout page, or partner integrations to start collecting bank account details and accepting ACH payments from customers.

  4. Stay compliant – Make sure you follow NACHA‘s operating rules, obtain proper authorizations, and protect sensitive customer data.

Credit Card Payments

  1. Choose a credit card processor – Compare rates, fees, and features from leading processors like Stripe, Square, PayPal, Authorize.Net, and merchant account providers.

  2. Apply for a merchant account – You‘ll need to complete an application and underwriting process with your chosen processor. This can take anywhere from a few minutes to several days.

  3. Set up payment acceptance – Depending on your business, you may need to integrate a payment gateway into your website, set up POS hardware like credit card terminals, or utilize a virtual terminal.

  4. Achieve PCI compliance – Work with your payment processor to ensure you‘re meeting the required security standards for accepting and transmitting cardholder data.

The Future of B2B and B2C Payments in 2024 and Beyond

2024 marks an exciting time for business payment processing. While ACH and credit cards remain the dominant players, several trends and innovations are shaping the future of how we pay and get paid. Here‘s what you can expect:

  • Real-time payments – The demand for instant payment settlement is driving the adoption of real-time payment networks like RTP and FedNow, which can process payments 24/7/365.

  • Embedded payments – Payment processing will become increasingly embedded into the software tools businesses use every day, like accounting, billing, and ERP systems. This will create a more seamless payment experience.

  • Contactless payments – The Covid-19 pandemic accelerated the shift to contactless payments, which will continue to gain popularity for in-person transactions. This includes mobile wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay.

  • B2B payment automation – More B2B buyers will ditch paper checks in favor of automated AP solutions that streamline payment processing, approvals, and reconciliation.

  • Crypto and blockchain – While still in the early stages, cryptocurrency and blockchain technology could disrupt traditional payment rails and offer new benefits like increased security and transparency.

As these trends take hold, it will be important for businesses to continuously evaluate their payment stack and adapt to changing customer preferences. Whether you prioritize ACH, credit cards, or emerging payment methods, having a trusted payment processor in your corner will be key to success.

The Bottom Line on ACH vs Credit Card Payments

There‘s no one-size-fits-all answer to whether your business should accept ACH or credit card payments. It depends on your unique needs, customers, and goals. But by understanding the key differences in cost, speed, security, and use cases, you can make an informed decision that supports your growth in 2024 and beyond.

If you‘re still unsure where to start, reach out to a payment processing expert who can assess your business and recommend the best path forward. With the right mix of ACH and credit card acceptance, you‘ll be well-positioned to maximize your payment potential in the years ahead.

Similar Posts