Open-Ended Questions Are Overrated: 5 Times Closed-Ended Queries Are Superior in Sales

As salespeople, we‘ve had it drilled into our heads that open-ended questions are the holy grail of sales conversations. And it‘s true – a thoughtful open-ended question can work wonders for uncovering a prospect‘s needs, hesitations, decision criteria and more.

But in our fervor to "always be asking open-ended questions", we‘ve somehow convinced ourselves that closed-ended questions (those that can be answered with a simple yes, no, or other one-word response) are nothing more than a cheap fallback for lazy reps. This couldn‘t be further from the truth.

When used strategically, closed-ended questions are an equally powerful weapon in any salesperson‘s arsenal. In fact, there are several common scenarios in which a closed-ended question will actually serve you far better than an open-ended one.

Let‘s dive into five of those and explore why a narrow, targeted question is exactly what you need to keep the deal moving forward.

1. When you need to confirm your understanding

One of the most underrated skills in sales is active listening – the ability to not just hear your prospect‘s words but to fully process and comprehend the meaning behind them. Considering that the average person only remembers 25-50% of what they hear, it‘s safe to say most of us could stand to sharpen our listening abilities.

A surefire way to ensure you‘re accurately interpreting what your prospect tells you is to play it back to them in your own words, then directly ask them to confirm you‘ve got it right. For example:

Prospect: Our main challenge right now is that our customer acquisition costs have skyrocketed over the past year. We‘re barely breaking even on each new customer, which is putting a huge strain on our cash flow and ability to invest in other areas of the business. My team needs to figure out how to bring those costs down without sacrificing the quality of the leads we‘re bringing in.

You: It sounds like your primary goal is to decrease your cost per acquisition and improve the efficiency of your customer acquisition process, while still maintaining a high bar for lead quality. Did I capture that correctly?

Asking a simple closed-ended question to validate your understanding gives the prospect a chance to correct any misconceptions, fill in missing pieces of information, or clarify their perspective. Plus, research from Gong.io found that checking for understanding makes prospects feel 30% more understood by the salesperson and significantly strengthens rapport.

Imagine if instead, you responded with an open-ended question like "Can you tell me more about that?" The prospect may be unsure which part you want them to expand on and end up going on a tangent about something entirely irrelevant. Validating your grasp of their core points ensures you have the full context needed to position your solution effectively.

2. When you want to re-engage a drifting prospect

We‘ve all been guilty of mentally checking out during a meeting that seems to drag on forever. Our prospects are no different, especially now that so many sales conversations happen over Zoom where distractions are plentiful and attention spans are fleeting.

In fact, a study from Microsoft found that the average human attention span has shrunk to just eight seconds – shorter than that of a goldfish! This means salespeople are tasked with the near-impossible challenge of keeping prospects laser-focused on the conversation at hand.

One simple tactic is to periodically pause your demo or presentation to ask the prospect a closed-ended question, such as:

"Does this align with what you had in mind?"
"Am I explaining this clearly?"
"Do you have any questions before I move on?"

Think of it like a teacher checking in to ensure her students are grasping the day‘s lesson. These closed-ended questions create natural inflection points that jolt the prospect out of their reverie and prompt them to re-engage, even if it‘s just for a few seconds. Open-ended questions are less effective in this scenario because they require the prospect to formulate a more extensive answer, which they‘re unlikely to do if they‘ve been tuning you out.

The data scientists at Gong analyzed over 500,000 sales calls and discovered that engaging the prospect throughout the meeting is one of the top five factors that predict a successful sales outcome. So if you notice your buyer‘s eyes start to glaze over, don‘t be afraid to lob a few yes-or-no questions at them to pull their attention back to the conversation.

3. When you need to nail down next steps

Stop me if this sounds familiar: you wrap up a great call with a prospect, exchange pleasantries, and say your goodbyes. Both parties leave with positive vibes…but no concrete plan of action. A day goes by, then a week, and suddenly you realize the deal hasn‘t progressed one iota since that last conversation.

This is an all-too-common scenario that plagues salespeople across industries. In fact, 60% of deals end up stalling because the rep and buyer failed to establish clear next steps.

The solution? Ditch the "I‘ll follow up with you soon" or "Let‘s touch base next week" in favor of closed-ended questions that lock in specific commitments, such as:

"Can we schedule our next meeting for Tuesday at 10am?"
"Are you comfortable introducing me to your VP of Operations now, or would you prefer to have an internal conversation with her first?"
"Shall I send over a proposal for your team to review?"

Not only does this approach make you appear buttoned up and organized, it‘s also harder for prospects to wiggle out of. If they say no, they‘ll feel compelled to propose an alternative, which still moves the ball forward.

Contrast this with an open-ended question like "What do you think our next steps should be?" that practically invites the prospect to respond with an ambiguous "Let me get back to you on that." Salespeople who use collaborative language to suggest (not demand) a clear path forward can boost their close rate by 10-15%, according to proprietary research from HubSpot.

4. When you need a specific piece of information

Prospects‘ time is valuable, and yours is too. While open-ended questions can produce fascinating insights, sometimes they come at the expense of efficiency.

If you‘re on a tight timeline or need to gather a key piece of information to determine whether an account is worth pursuing, a closed-ended question will help you extract it quickly without taking the conversation on a tangent. For instance:

You: For this engagement to be worthwhile for both of us, I typically look for opportunities that are at least $50,000 in revenue potential. Does this align with your expectations for budget?

Prospect: No, our budget is only around $30,000 for this initiative.

Now you have a clear go/no-go signal without having to spend precious meeting time on an open-ended detour. And since the average rep only has time to ask 5-8 questions over the course of a 30-minute discovery call, you better make them count.

Of course, this isn‘t to say you should just rapid-fire closed-ended questions at your prospect for 30 minutes straight. But peppering in a few carefully-chosen ones can help you speedily determine whether the opportunity is a good mutual fit.

The key is to do your research ahead of time so you know which specific details to probe on. That way, your closed-ended questions will come across as astute and respectful of the prospect‘s time, not generic and self-serving.

5. When you need the prospect to make a decision

Some buyers are naturally indecisive, or just like to keep their cards close to the vest. They‘ll waffle back and forth, refusing to commit to a firm stance one way or the other. This can be maddening for salespeople who need a clear read on where the buyer stands in order to tailor their approach accordingly.

One way to gently corner these evasive prospects into picking a lane is to present them with closed-ended questions that force their hand, such as:

"Based on what I‘ve shown you, could you envision our solution helping you achieve your goal of reducing time-to-hire by 20%?"
"From a features and functionality standpoint, does our platform check all the boxes on your ‘must-have‘ list?"
"Given our discussion today, do you feel confident our software would be a worthwhile investment for your team this year?"

It‘s much harder for the prospect to stay on the fence when you serve up a question with only a few possible answers. If they respond positively, you‘ll know you‘re heading in the right direction. If they express hesitation, you have an opening to dig into their reservations.

The psychology principle of cognitive dissonance states that people feel compelled to act in ways that are consistent with their stated beliefs. So once you get a waffling prospect to verbalize a clear opinion, they‘ll be more likely to behave accordingly.

I once had a buyer who kept flip-flopping on whether my company‘s software was a good fit for his team‘s needs. After several meandering conversations, I finally asked him point blank: "At the end of the day, do you feel confident our solution is the best one to help you hit your aggressive growth targets for this quarter?"

He hesitated, then admitted he had lingering concerns that the implementation and training would take too much of his team‘s time away from selling. Bingo! By nudging him to take a decisive stance, I uncovered the real blocker – his worry about the opportunity cost of deploying a new tool. I was then able to directly address his concern by pointing out how our software‘s automation features would ultimately save his reps time and quickly offset the onboarding period.

Had I continued to stick with open-ended questions, the buyer could have stayed noncommittal and I may never have gotten to the root of the issue. The well-timed closed-ended question was exactly what I needed to resurrect a deal on the brink of stalling out.

Bringing it all together

Now, I‘m not advocating for tossing out open-ended questions altogether. The skill of crafting thought-provoking, open-ended questions is one every rep must develop and leverage often. After all, a strategic open-ended question has an impressive track record of getting prospects to open up, share valuable context about their situation, and even convince themselves of the need for change.

But if you‘ve been treating closed-ended questions as nothing more than an amateurish crutch, it‘s time to rethink your stance. These targeted queries can be equally powerful for moving deals forward when used at the right moments, such as:

• Confirming your interpretation of the prospect‘s key points
• Re-engaging prospects who have mentally checked out of the conversation
• Establishing specific, mutually-agreed upon next steps
• Extracting a critical piece of information needed to qualify or disqualify the account
• Nudging non-committal prospects to take a firm stance

In other words, open-ended questions are the yin to closed-ended questions‘ yang. The most effective salespeople have learned to wield both types with intention and dexterity.

Knowing when to use an open-ended versus closed-ended question is both an art and a science. Like most things in sales, it takes practice and a healthy dose of trial and error to find the right balance. But once you master the ability to toggle between the two types based on your prospect‘s responses and the objectives of the conversation, you‘ll be well on your way to running more substantive, efficient sales discussions.

So the next time you find yourself in a sales conversation that‘s meandering off course, don‘t be afraid to lob a pointed yes-or-no question at your prospect. You may just find that a targeted closed-ended question is exactly what you need to get the deal unstuck and moving in the right direction.

Liked this article? For more actionable sales advice from today‘s top thought leaders, check out the HubSpot Sales Blog.